{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780","title":"候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？","kind":"research_note","reviewStatus":"structurally_screened_not_individually_reviewed","language":"zh-CN","category":"声画与理论笔记","series":"第八章负例档案","sourceVersionDate":"2026-07-14","publishedAt":"2026-09-08","modifiedAt":"2026-09-08T05:03:32+00:00","markdownUrl":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780.md","editionUrl":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/data/editions/hs-d2519250a5329780-f2362666e290419553a9.md","markdownSha256":"f2362666e290419553a9d37299108877b733ecbbe67bd4cf6267f6b69d5eddb2","markdownBytes":17662,"characters":5619,"sourceEvidenceTier":"T3_CASE_SYNTHESIS_FROM_P4_PUBLIC_CORPUS","sourceStatus":"draft","evidenceBoundary":"本页只证明P4公开语料中出现了批评、回应、汇编和若干后续招募差异，不据此证明批评已被接受、拒绝或转成规则。发布日相同不能建立文章先后，时间邻接不能建立因果，后出自我批评不能替代当时决定；缺少规则差证据不得写成确认未变。","editionNote":"本文为研究档案公开版，保留来源版本的论述与限制。公开时间：2026-09-08；不表示已完成同行评审。 本文属于公开研究资料（历史笔记、研究稿或来源记录）：已完成格式、来源限制与重复项筛查，尚未完成逐篇独立事实复核；原文中的解释、候选判断和未确认内容均按其原有限制阅读。","imageUrls":[],"links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-12795d60e5b323f5","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-2ab7eda2cb8bf062","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-2f722f0857fe160a","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-4619417eb4b3bb15","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-49e47dc01c0ca19f","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-4b1ba5deebefbd40","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-600d0a347e0dc2a0","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-6e4f86a3e003833a","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-78e468fde7b8b530","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-7b6bff5505c2e9ed","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-896079b3f7acd0b7","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-91bc02c388ed4da0","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-9771b16474ec7848","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-a764223f1db662cc","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-ad47ec028c39e2a0","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-b179272bf6c7ab2d","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-baf4154dbd8169f1","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d59ccdce6d3139bc","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d999b95febe31daf","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-e74ef300e46711e2","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-e806de5aa6c5f451","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-f035448f2c6ed356"],"relationMethod":"literal links and image references in the public edition; no inferred semantic support","paragraphCount":85,"markdown":"# 候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？\n\n本文为研究档案公开版，保留来源版本的论述与限制。公开时间：2026-09-08；不表示已完成同行评审。 本文属于公开研究资料（历史笔记、研究稿或来源记录）：已完成格式、来源限制与重复项筛查，尚未完成逐篇独立事实复核；原文中的解释、候选判断和未确认内容均按其原有限制阅读。\n\n来源版本日期：2026-07-14\n\n证据边界：本页只证明P4公开语料中出现了批评、回应、汇编和若干后续招募差异，不据此证明批评已被接受、拒绝或转成规则。发布日相同不能建立文章先后，时间邻接不能建立因果，后出自我批评不能替代当时决定；缺少规则差证据不得写成确认未变。\n\n# 候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？\n\n> 返回V2总入口（馆内参考，未随本文公开）；本案执行[第八章七字段闸门](/research/hs-7b6bff5505c2e9ed)。\n\n> [!warning] 当前裁决\n> 本案不是“《冰山》没有听取批评”的既成结论。现有材料反而明确证明，批评出现了、被P4账号公开了、遭到回应，也被整理为项目档案。真正未被证明的是：这些声音是否取得了进入决定的权限，是否使下一轮某条可执行规则发生了可归因的变化。因而本案保持`candidate_not_closed`。\n\n## 一、为什么“有回应”仍然可能是断链\n\n《冰山》是一个比“意见被压下去”更难处理的案例。2022年1月1日公演之后，P4的公开页面并没有只留下自我表扬。1月6日，“p4剧场和你”同日发布了观众批评、另一位观众的不同理解以及多篇“北风社论”；2月2日，“p4剧场”又用[《捕鼠器》](/research/hs-49e47dc01c0ca19f)把招募、排练、演出、观众意见、论坛和对话等片段编排成一次回顾。就公开可见性而言，这条通道并不弱。\n\n问题恰在这里。一个组织完全可以让批评成为内容，却不让批评成为决定；可以公开一句尖锐的话，再用更强的账号、标题、编排和回应把它收回自己的叙事；也可以真诚反思，却始终没有形成谁接收、谁答复、谁表决、谁执行、谁复核的程序。[《怎样证明一次返回》](/research/hs-6e4f86a3e003833a)要求把“痕迹出现—进入通道—形成判断—造成后态差异”逐边证明。《冰山》目前可以走到第二步，第三、四步尚未闭合。\n\n## 二、最窄时间线\n\n| 日期 | 公开材料支持的最小事实 | 不能据此推出 |\n|---|---|---|\n| 2021-06-30 | 早期招募写到参与者“会通过选拔”，并提出激进、台上台下融合、自我批判等愿望。见[《冰山》招募](/research/hs-d999b95febe31daf)。 | 不能把这篇早期招募直接当作2022年1月最终运行规则。 |\n| 2021-12-07 | 何发署名的[北风剧社招募](/research/hs-4b1ba5deebefbd40)公布九条原则：互相批评、自我批评、不隐瞒观点、不回避矛盾，专业与素人均可进入。 | 原则没有说明意见怎样取得约束力，也不能证明所有成员共同确认。 |\n| 2022-01-01 | 后续同期文本确认《冰山》完成公演；开票文案写明仅15席。 | 不能由“15号观众”称谓反推实名、座次制度或完整观众名单。 |\n| 2022-01-06 | [15号观众批评](/research/hs-4619417eb4b3bb15)与多篇北风社论集中公开。 | 同一发布日期没有分钟级顺序，不能断定哪一篇专门回应哪一篇。 |\n| 2022-01-30—02-02 | 项目文本把《冰山》称为失败实验并进入下一戏招募；《捕鼠器》将多种片段收为回顾。 | 反思与汇编不等于作出规则决定。 |\n| 2022-02-08 | [《漩涡》招募](/research/hs-e806de5aa6c5f451)要求创作者参与剧本、表演、声音、灯光、装置、宣传、记录等环节。 | 《冰山》本就被后出文本描述为反导演中心、集体创作，故这可能是延续而非变化。 |\n| 2022-04-08 | [《冰山》2.0招募](/research/hs-d59ccdce6d3139bc)写“无门槛、无要求、来者皆是北风”。 | 尚无同期文本把门槛变化归因于1月批评，也无材料证明招募与演出按此执行。 |\n| 2022-11-30 | 曲文豪署名文本回看从“给百分之九十的人写戏”走向“观众已死”、从合作走向支配，并写自己后来听不见批评。见[《必须重新为百分之九十的人写戏》](/research/hs-600d0a347e0dc2a0)。 | 这是重要自我反证，却不能代替受影响者证词，也不能反推1月以后每条规则均未改变。 |\n\n## 三、七字段账\n\n| 字段 | 当前可写判断 | 闭合状态 |\n|---|---|---|\n| `rule_before` | 可确认一组公开原则：开放专业／素人、互相批评、自我批评、不回避矛盾、尊重发起人冲动、共同表达。看不见的是反馈议程、裁决、申诉、报酬、退出和善后程序。 | 部分闭合 |\n| `result` | 观众批评指出文本与呈现空洞、创作关系散漫、观众受骗与不受尊重；另有观众反对刻板阶级判断；内部文本又提出无导演、低预算、角色难进入、希望商业化等不同问题。 | 已闭合到“公开表达出现” |\n| `return_channel` | 演后交流的第一方叙述、1月6日公众号集中发布、2月2日汇编归档三层入口存在。 | 入口存在；接收责任未闭合 |\n| `decision` | 未见谁把哪些意见列入议程，谁采纳、驳回或决定不处理；更未见决定日期与理由。 | 缺证 |\n| `rule_after` | 可见全环节共创与“无门槛”两项后续表述，但没有足够的前后版本、因果说明和实施记录。 | 候选 |\n| `no_change_evidence` | 没有一份材料足以证明旧惯例在后续被重复执行。口号延续与后来承认听不见批评，只能作为压力材料。 | 未闭合 |\n| `right_to_end` | 当事人当前是否愿意再次被引用、是否只许匿名、能否撤回，均未确认。 | 未闭合 |\n\n## 四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置\n\n**观众位置。**“15号观众”并不是一条抽象负面评价，而是把问题指向作品的内核、舞台呈现、创作者协作以及对观众的尊重；另一篇[观众批评](/research/hs-91bc02c388ed4da0)则从个人解读与阶级刻板印象出发，并不与前者同声。两篇都被公开，恰好说明“观众意见”不能被压成赞成或反对两格。\n\n**发起人与主创位置。**2021年12月材料把曲文豪写为编剧和北风发起人之一，何发则叙述剧团形成、九条原则与P4前史；但1月6日几篇“北风社论”的语料作者栏为空，不能全部署到曲文豪、何发或全体剧社名下。[《关于剧社和〈冰山〉随笔》](/research/hs-baf4154dbd8169f1)呈现的还是一位演员式内部位置：对剧本、无导演状态、预算和创作动力均有不满，同时希望剧社变好。它与攻击观众批评能力的[《北风致辞》](/research/hs-12795d60e5b323f5)并非同一种回应。\n\n**何发与P4位置。**何发可以为自己署名的12月招募和7月回溯负责，却不能因掌握P4历史叙述位置而自动代表全部北风成员。现有公开链可以证明P4双账号承载了这些文本，不能证明何发亲自编辑1月6日全部文章，更不能证明P4、北风剧社与每一位主创具有同一决定权。\n\n**维护者与编辑位置。**有人收稿、命名栏目、安排同日发布，并在《捕鼠器》中决定哪些片段成为可点击的项目史；但现有材料没有给出这一维护者是谁、是否保留原稿、删去过什么、是否将文章送还作者复核。维护劳动使反声可见，也掌握反声的第二次命名权。若不恢复这个位置，档案看上去很多声，决定结构仍可能只有一个中心。\n\n## 五、后续究竟改变了什么\n\n当前最像规则差的是《冰山》2.0从早期“通过选拔”转向“无门槛、无要求”。然而两篇招募相隔九个月，中间经历北风剧社成立、场地变化、人员变化与杭州驻地机会；外部条件足以解释门槛改变。除非找到会议记录、招募稿版本或发起人同期说明，明确说某条观众或演员批评促成了这一改动，否则只能记为时间相邻的差异。\n\n《漩涡》要求八位创作者参与制作各环节，也不能轻易算作改规。1月30日的项目反思已经把《冰山》自述为“杀死导演”、演员共同创作的实验；2月8日更详尽的分工清单，既可能是失败后的制度化，也可能只是把原有意图写得更清楚。真正需要的不是另一篇漂亮宣言，而是《冰山》与《漩涡》的招募协议、排练运行单、实际分工、冲突处理与退出记录的前后对照。\n\n至于15号观众提出的“不尊重”“受骗”和基本呈现问题，目前看不到对应的新规则：有没有更清楚的预演说明，有没有票务退改或预期管理，有没有批评接收人、答复期限、未采纳理由，有没有让观众或演员进入下一轮决定。公开材料没有给出这些答案。这里应写“缺少决定证据”，不能写“剧社拒绝改变”。\n\n## 六、什么才算`no_change_evidence`\n\n负例不能靠搜索无果成立。能够关闭本案的未变证据，至少应是以下一类：下一项目仍按同一旧程序运行，并由运行单、现场记录和两种位置证词交叉确认；会议明确讨论了该批评，决定不修改且留下理由；某项宣布修改的规则在实际调用时失效；提出批评的人仍只能发言，不能提案、复核、申诉或否决。现有材料还没有达到这个强度。\n\n曲文豪2022年11月的自我批评尤其需要克制使用。它承认创作关系可能由合作转成支配，后来的批评和讨论也可能“听不见”，这足以反驳“1月公开批评以后，反馈机制已经稳定建立”的乐观叙述；但它仍是一位主创对长时段经历的自述，不是1月批评处理账，也不是每位参与者认可的组织结论。它使本案更值得追问，尚不能使本案自动获判。\n\n## 七、结束权不是最后补签的一栏\n\n“15号观众”保持编号身份，其他1月文本也多无作者字段。研究不能据此追索或猜测实名。历史公众号公开只证明文本曾被公开，不证明作者愿意被十万字根本文本重新组织为P4的负例。进入正式章节以前，应把原文、拟引用段落、本案判断和可选身份方式分别送还相关者；允许保留匿名、删去可识别细节、只做材料引用而不接受理论归类，或完全退出。\n\n若无法联系当事人，本案仍可在内部研究账中保留为公开材料审计，但不应补写其心理、动机与后续遭遇。若当事人要求停止，删除正文接口即可；不能把“他拒绝再谈”变成递归媒介学又一次吸收异议的素材。\n\n## 八、阶段裁决\n\n### 已证\n\n- 《冰山》于2022年1月1日公演，随后公开出现至少两种观众位置和多种北风内部／回应位置。\n- P4双账号不仅刊发批评，还在《捕鼠器》中建立了后出汇编入口。\n- 后续招募文本出现全环节共创与“无门槛、无要求”等可比较表述。\n- 2022年11月，曲文豪公开反省从合作滑向支配、从面向观众滑向听不见批评的风险。\n\n### 候选\n\n- 《冰山》的批评可能促成了下一项目对共创职责的写明。\n- 《冰山》2.0的开放招募可能是对早期门槛和组织失败的修正。\n- 同期批评的公开可能主要完成了“表达返回”，尚未完成“决定返回”。\n\n### 缺证\n\n- 1月6日各文章的投稿、编辑、发布时间顺序与作者复核记录；\n- 演后谈完整录音、现场主持人、发言名单和未公开意见；\n- 对批评的正式议程、决定者、采纳／驳回理由与答复；\n- 《冰山》1.0、《漩涡》《冰山》2.0的规则版本差与实际执行；\n- 票款、预算、报酬、排练纪律、退出、冲突处理和善后规则；\n- 观众、演员、发起人、何发／P4与账号维护者的分别复核；\n- 每位相关者当前的引用、匿名、撤回和结束选择。\n\n### 反证条件\n\n以下任一材料出现，都可能使本案不再是负例候选：一份同期会议或聊天明确把某条观众／演员批评转写为具体规则；下一项目的运行记录证明该规则被实际调用；批评者取得提案、复核、否决或申诉权并成功使用；《冰山》2.0发起人能以同期文件说明开放招募正是对1月结果的回应。反之，若找到明确“不改”的决定、宣布的新规实际未执行，或下一项目重复相同问题的连续证据，本案才可能升级为闭合负例。\n\n### Owner碰撞点\n\n1. 1月1日演后交流由谁设计、主持和记录？它是自由发言、轮流发言，还是被点名发言？\n2. “15号观众”的文章由谁收取，是否经过改题、删节或合并，作者是否同意公开？\n3. 1月6日各篇的真实先后是什么；《北风致辞》回应的是现场、某篇文章，还是泛指一类观众？\n4. 谁掌握“p4剧场”和“p4剧场和你”的发布权限，谁决定《捕鼠器》的收录与排序？\n5. 演后是否召开过一次真正的决定会议；哪条意见被采纳、哪条被拒绝、哪条无人处理？\n6. 《漩涡》的全环节共创清单在《冰山》之前是否已经存在；若是失败后新增，具体由谁提出？\n7. 《冰山》2.0为何改成“无门槛、无要求”；这是批评回流、人员不足、驻地条件，还是另一原因？\n8. 对“观众受骗／不受尊重”的批评，后来是否出现过预期说明、退票、答复期限或申诉程序？\n9. 哪位演员、观众或维护者能指出：公开文章之外，实际工作方式究竟变了什么？\n10. 有哪些意见没有进入公众号，谁决定不发，原稿是否还在？\n11. 15号观众及其他作者今天是否愿意进入本书，允许怎样称呼、引用和退出？\n12. 如果他们要求本案结束，哪些正文、引文与档案索引应立即停止使用？\n\n## 九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核\n\n### 后续节点使“没有改变”更难成立\n\n本轮不是继续搜集“P4曾经反思过”的文本，而是检查负例所需的反事实链。2022年2月8日的[《漩涡》招募](/research/hs-e806de5aa6c5f451)把全环节集体创作写得更具体；4月8日的[《冰山》2.0招募](/research/hs-d59ccdce6d3139bc)又出现“无门槛、无要求”的开放表述；11月30日的[后出自我批评](/research/hs-600d0a347e0dc2a0)则承认合作可能滑向支配、批评可能被“听不见”。\n\n这些节点不能证明1月的批评已经造成改规，却会阻止我们把本案轻易判成“什么都没有变”。后续文本至少呈现了不同的制度候选：共创职责被明写、招募门槛被重述、发起人对“听不见”做出了公开承认。如果不能证明这些差异与旧惯例无关、没有执行，或在实际冲突中失效，就不能用“后来仍无变化”来封口。\n\n### 缺口仍在决定层与执行层\n\n第二轮复核仍未找到以下链条：哪一条《冰山》观众或成员批评被哪个人或会议纳入议程；决定了修改、不修改还是暂缓的具体理由；新规则何时被写入招募、排练或演出运行；它在一次真实冲突中是否被调用；提出批评的人是否能复核“这是我的意见造成的差异”。现有公开文本完成的仍然主要是表达、编辑和归档，而不是从返回到决定、从决定到执行的责任链。\n\n### 第二轮裁决\n\n本案继续保持`candidate_not_closed`。它不是闭合的负例，也不能因为后续出现差异文本就升级为正例。当前最准确的说法是：**批评的表达返回与档案返回已经可见；决定返回、可归因的规则差和执行结果仍未闭合；而后续变化候选又使“旧惯例明确未变”同样无法成立。**\n\n## 十、研究接线\n\n本案用[递归媒介学](/research/hs-78e468fde7b8b530)检验批评是否返回决定，以[事件组织权](/research/hs-b179272bf6c7ab2d)追问谁采纳或拒绝，以[结束权](/research/hs-f035448f2c6ed356)限制对批评者的继续调用；[冰山](/research/hs-2f722f0857fe160a)只提供项目关联，不预先裁定组织效果。P4剧场（馆内参考，未随本文公开）与何发（馆内参考，未随本文公开）分别作为平台／组织和具名叙述位置出现，不能覆盖北风成员、观众与退出者。\n\n语料边界回到P4网站与705篇公众号语料库（馆内参考，未随本文公开）。批评前结构只把[《给百分之九十的人写戏》](/research/hs-a764223f1db662cc)与[《冰山》首演开票](/research/hs-9771b16474ec7848)作为公开主张；同期内部异议另接[《撕掉我的名字》](/research/hs-896079b3f7acd0b7)。后续位置材料包括[1月30日招募](/research/hs-e74ef300e46711e2)、[5月观察日记](/research/hs-ad47ec028c39e2a0)与[7月18日后出回溯](/research/hs-2ab7eda2cb8bf062)；它们只构成日期、公开叙述或变化候选，不能补出批评因果。\n\n候选状态回到第八章负例总入口（馆内参考，未随本文公开），当事人口述入口在第八章问卷（馆内参考，未随本文公开）；权利与规则差字段沿用P4条件反写账本（馆内参考，未随本文公开），不因字段齐全而假定事实齐全。","paragraphs":[{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-217751974b8031a4-1","anchor":"p-217751974b8031a4-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-217751974b8031a4-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？"],"text":"候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？","textSha256":"e1b2bf88a0007953aa4e3c619189ec485953e77ddd7cf81269fa8c86725b0c27","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0fe7aa51c766a021-1","anchor":"p-0fe7aa51c766a021-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0fe7aa51c766a021-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？"],"text":"返回V2总入口（馆内参考，未随本文公开）；本案执行 第八章七字段闸门 。","textSha256":"5ca02cef74d98ed5d3337c5ceed24e59c9a83c3ea0bbc82319cedbebcb3de005","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-7b6bff5505c2e9ed"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-071df2c74fb02b06-1","anchor":"p-071df2c74fb02b06-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-071df2c74fb02b06-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["候选负例B｜《冰山》：批评被回应以后，规则变了吗？"],"text":"[!warning] 当前裁决\n本案不是“《冰山》没有听取批评”的既成结论。现有材料反而明确证明，批评出现了、被P4账号公开了、遭到回应，也被整理为项目档案。真正未被证明的是：这些声音是否取得了进入决定的权限，是否使下一轮某条可执行规则发生了可归因的变化。因而本案保持 candidate_not_closed 。","textSha256":"a29605176963d7afbf554828c7eef16d337f008e83ecfe8846ae7c4be8f15ac3","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e587f0c650800cc9-1","anchor":"p-e587f0c650800cc9-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e587f0c650800cc9-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["一、为什么“有回应”仍然可能是断链"],"text":"一、为什么“有回应”仍然可能是断链","textSha256":"533b8c4293d51a08fe96abbdc2b19a1656b40537cfe23e4833fadff049c08cec","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d22d1280f322340b-1","anchor":"p-d22d1280f322340b-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d22d1280f322340b-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["一、为什么“有回应”仍然可能是断链"],"text":"《冰山》是一个比“意见被压下去”更难处理的案例。2022年1月1日公演之后，P4的公开页面并没有只留下自我表扬。1月6日，“p4剧场和你”同日发布了观众批评、另一位观众的不同理解以及多篇“北风社论”；2月2日，“p4剧场”又用 《捕鼠器》 把招募、排练、演出、观众意见、论坛和对话等片段编排成一次回顾。就公开可见性而言，这条通道并不弱。","textSha256":"bf5aa121a28e06cb00cee5bbeaf3437f404fa56849142c228cedeed32dbc6ad5","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-49e47dc01c0ca19f"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-dd0721d94c7896ac-1","anchor":"p-dd0721d94c7896ac-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-dd0721d94c7896ac-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["一、为什么“有回应”仍然可能是断链"],"text":"问题恰在这里。一个组织完全可以让批评成为内容，却不让批评成为决定；可以公开一句尖锐的话，再用更强的账号、标题、编排和回应把它收回自己的叙事；也可以真诚反思，却始终没有形成谁接收、谁答复、谁表决、谁执行、谁复核的程序。 《怎样证明一次返回》 要求把“痕迹出现—进入通道—形成判断—造成后态差异”逐边证明。《冰山》目前可以走到第二步，第三、四步尚未闭合。","textSha256":"ba0ca1be6b48ec5d25ddd4950f442e12a94d213ea7aecb6b03cc5992088a7161","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-6e4f86a3e003833a"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e802ff4c3dd93491-1","anchor":"p-e802ff4c3dd93491-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e802ff4c3dd93491-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"二、最窄时间线","textSha256":"f7287341150e2825127deeb51f7f70a024938b7db827ad489ac034e09c796b71","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-9021672629d29665-1","anchor":"p-9021672629d29665-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-9021672629d29665-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"日期 公开材料支持的最小事实 不能据此推出","textSha256":"6c4a2ccd70948045e445d219c1bb8d6af90b2202828649d4163ef26933f9f908","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4570c0a1eb4b295e-1","anchor":"p-4570c0a1eb4b295e-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4570c0a1eb4b295e-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2021-06-30 早期招募写到参与者“会通过选拔”，并提出激进、台上台下融合、自我批判等愿望。见 《冰山》招募 。 不能把这篇早期招募直接当作2022年1月最终运行规则。","textSha256":"b10e888db01c3568fb1298daf5143033f7a7476abb8eae86b56a6023247192b2","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d999b95febe31daf"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-32715bdcf1e5db94-1","anchor":"p-32715bdcf1e5db94-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-32715bdcf1e5db94-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2021-12-07 何发署名的 北风剧社招募 公布九条原则：互相批评、自我批评、不隐瞒观点、不回避矛盾，专业与素人均可进入。 原则没有说明意见怎样取得约束力，也不能证明所有成员共同确认。","textSha256":"22b3bade9b0fab319257566ab628da905692b69d7e707ba1e17d30e4063994ac","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-4b1ba5deebefbd40"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-da560f23c387b97d-1","anchor":"p-da560f23c387b97d-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-da560f23c387b97d-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-01-01 后续同期文本确认《冰山》完成公演；开票文案写明仅15席。 不能由“15号观众”称谓反推实名、座次制度或完整观众名单。","textSha256":"d9c03683d0e84a64bd1bdfccd3f79552a4215126090ea06469b859cc76d94c70","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-67f24bf874554852-1","anchor":"p-67f24bf874554852-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-67f24bf874554852-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-01-06 15号观众批评 与多篇北风社论集中公开。 同一发布日期没有分钟级顺序，不能断定哪一篇专门回应哪一篇。","textSha256":"61d8304e1d0d87d965be4268ce2c529840c7efbd65bd473fc08a4973431190cf","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-4619417eb4b3bb15"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e6f7392aaef9c52d-1","anchor":"p-e6f7392aaef9c52d-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e6f7392aaef9c52d-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-01-30—02-02 项目文本把《冰山》称为失败实验并进入下一戏招募；《捕鼠器》将多种片段收为回顾。 反思与汇编不等于作出规则决定。","textSha256":"fcfbd3253e0aaef7d90f4b6e86d930f0a038635e92dd9c42dac5cc4ce705a04a","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-93e8653b76151397-1","anchor":"p-93e8653b76151397-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-93e8653b76151397-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-02-08 《漩涡》招募 要求创作者参与剧本、表演、声音、灯光、装置、宣传、记录等环节。 《冰山》本就被后出文本描述为反导演中心、集体创作，故这可能是延续而非变化。","textSha256":"db9c01d762f1a86ddec1f19b031a005b23a24a970dc3ca0d7e901e630e6f87e9","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-e806de5aa6c5f451"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-b6481411c78e6aa3-1","anchor":"p-b6481411c78e6aa3-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-b6481411c78e6aa3-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-04-08 《冰山》2.0招募 写“无门槛、无要求、来者皆是北风”。 尚无同期文本把门槛变化归因于1月批评，也无材料证明招募与演出按此执行。","textSha256":"992b0c7551c4e54385795fa61e6dad6b5034bb8e0dbbf5aab6b052b62bc65d3d","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d59ccdce6d3139bc"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ad8a3dbbb5d75d2a-1","anchor":"p-ad8a3dbbb5d75d2a-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ad8a3dbbb5d75d2a-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["二、最窄时间线"],"text":"2022-11-30 曲文豪署名文本回看从“给百分之九十的人写戏”走向“观众已死”、从合作走向支配，并写自己后来听不见批评。见 《必须重新为百分之九十的人写戏》 。 这是重要自我反证，却不能代替受影响者证词，也不能反推1月以后每条规则均未改变。","textSha256":"0d25442e0d0473b21a2021a49660508acda5819ed537c5c16b572141c2f7048b","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-600d0a347e0dc2a0"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-9906aad2c9f57aa9-1","anchor":"p-9906aad2c9f57aa9-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-9906aad2c9f57aa9-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"三、七字段账","textSha256":"1319785d11e4d6ee1abfcffbb0a8eda5d94e25a56053f2f0047639edfe526c15","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-5263b18e4556cfb7-1","anchor":"p-5263b18e4556cfb7-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-5263b18e4556cfb7-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"字段 当前可写判断 闭合状态","textSha256":"2d21514e242685c574b4c14e86ce11779c38c53d9632e43852bf7286f9e0a5c9","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7f002f7a4d468ac0-1","anchor":"p-7f002f7a4d468ac0-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7f002f7a4d468ac0-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"rule_before 可确认一组公开原则：开放专业／素人、互相批评、自我批评、不回避矛盾、尊重发起人冲动、共同表达。看不见的是反馈议程、裁决、申诉、报酬、退出和善后程序。 部分闭合","textSha256":"b2ea5c02c513c9246ef1ff9064920da972e200d439ff52f454dc35663c59c881","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4e0e29e4f66791bd-1","anchor":"p-4e0e29e4f66791bd-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4e0e29e4f66791bd-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"result 观众批评指出文本与呈现空洞、创作关系散漫、观众受骗与不受尊重；另有观众反对刻板阶级判断；内部文本又提出无导演、低预算、角色难进入、希望商业化等不同问题。 已闭合到“公开表达出现”","textSha256":"511a9d6a2dd782987a1f98f5bd5f0b62340c71684e4a598a783b7734e1e3b821","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-edf7a7884a12bb1a-1","anchor":"p-edf7a7884a12bb1a-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-edf7a7884a12bb1a-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"return_channel 演后交流的第一方叙述、1月6日公众号集中发布、2月2日汇编归档三层入口存在。 入口存在；接收责任未闭合","textSha256":"1db514ea71c74a41aac6c3057e6af7af7564f27195f62372329e1cfae60c471f","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7c9058650fdb864c-1","anchor":"p-7c9058650fdb864c-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7c9058650fdb864c-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"decision 未见谁把哪些意见列入议程，谁采纳、驳回或决定不处理；更未见决定日期与理由。 缺证","textSha256":"7978f165c1f8db193df859a0cc8a0b84d453a4b92be95e82b2309abb46ca6269","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ec00041f9fa90aec-1","anchor":"p-ec00041f9fa90aec-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ec00041f9fa90aec-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"rule_after 可见全环节共创与“无门槛”两项后续表述，但没有足够的前后版本、因果说明和实施记录。 候选","textSha256":"4fd93a2a8b60ed7a5de748d6b0b4251cca5fb853c48ab3966263c0daefdcf266","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7035f12f305aaf04-1","anchor":"p-7035f12f305aaf04-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7035f12f305aaf04-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"no_change_evidence 没有一份材料足以证明旧惯例在后续被重复执行。口号延续与后来承认听不见批评，只能作为压力材料。 未闭合","textSha256":"4053ee7805e8d76517a03126b11797fba612a764f22c5378c48eb4c0c8909b76","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-31187ff28d8bde75-1","anchor":"p-31187ff28d8bde75-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-31187ff28d8bde75-1","kind":"tr","headingPath":["三、七字段账"],"text":"right_to_end 当事人当前是否愿意再次被引用、是否只许匿名、能否撤回，均未确认。 未闭合","textSha256":"aaf82584ee87bf4e0346efe991664fbce9dc8137aca4372323ead4c7345b2368","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a4b51183d3e85b83-1","anchor":"p-a4b51183d3e85b83-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a4b51183d3e85b83-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置"],"text":"四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置","textSha256":"551542b7d5eb4e6a5d8081705a8bb6a535e552f45b54202b5d2f552350171c9c","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-803d452a926fcae6-1","anchor":"p-803d452a926fcae6-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-803d452a926fcae6-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置"],"text":"观众位置。 “15号观众”并不是一条抽象负面评价，而是把问题指向作品的内核、舞台呈现、创作者协作以及对观众的尊重；另一篇 观众批评 则从个人解读与阶级刻板印象出发，并不与前者同声。两篇都被公开，恰好说明“观众意见”不能被压成赞成或反对两格。","textSha256":"865640757c6f7fc0423cfafbd3131d8198e55c795657fad9f2be1a2cb3c0dd75","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-91bc02c388ed4da0"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-83dfbaa6819a75de-1","anchor":"p-83dfbaa6819a75de-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-83dfbaa6819a75de-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置"],"text":"发起人与主创位置。 2021年12月材料把曲文豪写为编剧和北风发起人之一，何发则叙述剧团形成、九条原则与P4前史；但1月6日几篇“北风社论”的语料作者栏为空，不能全部署到曲文豪、何发或全体剧社名下。 《关于剧社和〈冰山〉随笔》 呈现的还是一位演员式内部位置：对剧本、无导演状态、预算和创作动力均有不满，同时希望剧社变好。它与攻击观众批评能力的 《北风致辞》 并非同一种回应。","textSha256":"334cb2c25f5b64b8a8e3cbf4bceaaa3a4d3f519b7c55c0a7899258b2d9a28b05","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-12795d60e5b323f5","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-baf4154dbd8169f1"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ed73e4884be9d273-1","anchor":"p-ed73e4884be9d273-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ed73e4884be9d273-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置"],"text":"何发与P4位置。 何发可以为自己署名的12月招募和7月回溯负责，却不能因掌握P4历史叙述位置而自动代表全部北风成员。现有公开链可以证明P4双账号承载了这些文本，不能证明何发亲自编辑1月6日全部文章，更不能证明P4、北风剧社与每一位主创具有同一决定权。","textSha256":"097754aba7b0d506112934475e791794c0207e97a72a8915c7c7f43f2b430e14","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e7a9e108e4d5374b-1","anchor":"p-e7a9e108e4d5374b-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e7a9e108e4d5374b-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["四、不能被合并成一个“北风声音”的位置"],"text":"维护者与编辑位置。 有人收稿、命名栏目、安排同日发布，并在《捕鼠器》中决定哪些片段成为可点击的项目史；但现有材料没有给出这一维护者是谁、是否保留原稿、删去过什么、是否将文章送还作者复核。维护劳动使反声可见，也掌握反声的第二次命名权。若不恢复这个位置，档案看上去很多声，决定结构仍可能只有一个中心。","textSha256":"9dc6eac4855ec098a83097ca184f6f49bb1ddafa711b0ccd08b90ffe2e063c5b","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-29ddfd547158c892-1","anchor":"p-29ddfd547158c892-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-29ddfd547158c892-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["五、后续究竟改变了什么"],"text":"五、后续究竟改变了什么","textSha256":"f23b2100b7b3dfdd60b30c8dadec2083ab1733898b13b734621e942909754704","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bdd2f4632a502f71-1","anchor":"p-bdd2f4632a502f71-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bdd2f4632a502f71-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["五、后续究竟改变了什么"],"text":"当前最像规则差的是《冰山》2.0从早期“通过选拔”转向“无门槛、无要求”。然而两篇招募相隔九个月，中间经历北风剧社成立、场地变化、人员变化与杭州驻地机会；外部条件足以解释门槛改变。除非找到会议记录、招募稿版本或发起人同期说明，明确说某条观众或演员批评促成了这一改动，否则只能记为时间相邻的差异。","textSha256":"3bfc53b23c79fa54b2cb5bafbe1da3d3c8e4fdc49daf4b6448a37d9035281849","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0f078623d93fd861-1","anchor":"p-0f078623d93fd861-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0f078623d93fd861-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["五、后续究竟改变了什么"],"text":"《漩涡》要求八位创作者参与制作各环节，也不能轻易算作改规。1月30日的项目反思已经把《冰山》自述为“杀死导演”、演员共同创作的实验；2月8日更详尽的分工清单，既可能是失败后的制度化，也可能只是把原有意图写得更清楚。真正需要的不是另一篇漂亮宣言，而是《冰山》与《漩涡》的招募协议、排练运行单、实际分工、冲突处理与退出记录的前后对照。","textSha256":"00bd4b507600d7e557305ed97e6f96d55b823d1685a123a43a64f22b06339fe5","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bb7f4caeb6030b4e-1","anchor":"p-bb7f4caeb6030b4e-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bb7f4caeb6030b4e-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["五、后续究竟改变了什么"],"text":"至于15号观众提出的“不尊重”“受骗”和基本呈现问题，目前看不到对应的新规则：有没有更清楚的预演说明，有没有票务退改或预期管理，有没有批评接收人、答复期限、未采纳理由，有没有让观众或演员进入下一轮决定。公开材料没有给出这些答案。这里应写“缺少决定证据”，不能写“剧社拒绝改变”。","textSha256":"f511d72b2a14520cde4f74fd6aef59c804c96934a0dafd66a5579fc1d4040273","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-92e4574d2a6736e2-1","anchor":"p-92e4574d2a6736e2-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-92e4574d2a6736e2-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["六、什么才算 no_change_evidence"],"text":"六、什么才算 no_change_evidence","textSha256":"e6e13ce72f7a6a3e09114b252254ba0750e0fec3635b04ef9c5545e68ff79409","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-8a4568c05b4c1737-1","anchor":"p-8a4568c05b4c1737-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-8a4568c05b4c1737-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["六、什么才算 no_change_evidence"],"text":"负例不能靠搜索无果成立。能够关闭本案的未变证据，至少应是以下一类：下一项目仍按同一旧程序运行，并由运行单、现场记录和两种位置证词交叉确认；会议明确讨论了该批评，决定不修改且留下理由；某项宣布修改的规则在实际调用时失效；提出批评的人仍只能发言，不能提案、复核、申诉或否决。现有材料还没有达到这个强度。","textSha256":"94dcd409bb6378c35bbd2f091d50284a63fdf40cb6e146b8df82f90dcd7716a6","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-56fc883cb7b7e696-1","anchor":"p-56fc883cb7b7e696-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-56fc883cb7b7e696-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["六、什么才算 no_change_evidence"],"text":"曲文豪2022年11月的自我批评尤其需要克制使用。它承认创作关系可能由合作转成支配，后来的批评和讨论也可能“听不见”，这足以反驳“1月公开批评以后，反馈机制已经稳定建立”的乐观叙述；但它仍是一位主创对长时段经历的自述，不是1月批评处理账，也不是每位参与者认可的组织结论。它使本案更值得追问，尚不能使本案自动获判。","textSha256":"044028fa5ee9809868a930f5aa4ab9a3aeafc9289f1c4a7b0817ef41483893cb","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-6124e123c66be577-1","anchor":"p-6124e123c66be577-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-6124e123c66be577-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["七、结束权不是最后补签的一栏"],"text":"七、结束权不是最后补签的一栏","textSha256":"6ff99e5262c055d26bdafe1d2297c734f6f608ae505ea4d76686d66d03a48fe4","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ea5d92c4f5339fb9-1","anchor":"p-ea5d92c4f5339fb9-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ea5d92c4f5339fb9-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["七、结束权不是最后补签的一栏"],"text":"“15号观众”保持编号身份，其他1月文本也多无作者字段。研究不能据此追索或猜测实名。历史公众号公开只证明文本曾被公开，不证明作者愿意被十万字根本文本重新组织为P4的负例。进入正式章节以前，应把原文、拟引用段落、本案判断和可选身份方式分别送还相关者；允许保留匿名、删去可识别细节、只做材料引用而不接受理论归类，或完全退出。","textSha256":"cc38d46ba34bc184723e42171803202b3d83b42107148b0b1a6e3c74548c767f","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-f9558e3ee3389631-1","anchor":"p-f9558e3ee3389631-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-f9558e3ee3389631-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["七、结束权不是最后补签的一栏"],"text":"若无法联系当事人，本案仍可在内部研究账中保留为公开材料审计，但不应补写其心理、动机与后续遭遇。若当事人要求停止，删除正文接口即可；不能把“他拒绝再谈”变成递归媒介学又一次吸收异议的素材。","textSha256":"9b9aa63a507b6b423269cb17137fbda6d4439d03705dc2ad5734c673efc5605b","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a40141acd59df421-1","anchor":"p-a40141acd59df421-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a40141acd59df421-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决"],"text":"八、阶段裁决","textSha256":"c807eff4c2630a2c8ddad13ef49ee5f66ba2f234e0fd8e2384c05e799e1c2674","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-63536f080be4c331-1","anchor":"p-63536f080be4c331-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-63536f080be4c331-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","已证"],"text":"已证","textSha256":"fe58ffaeb93752b46a5fd6419e20390ca7fd3ed4a52dcfd8aa3fb5a43553715d","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-edc1ca8a1b142bee-1","anchor":"p-edc1ca8a1b142bee-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-edc1ca8a1b142bee-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","已证"],"text":"《冰山》于2022年1月1日公演，随后公开出现至少两种观众位置和多种北风内部／回应位置。","textSha256":"85b70b8c1802493fadb88077c2aac176a7384c317edf537a7351fe9a57195365","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ed729b6229442b15-1","anchor":"p-ed729b6229442b15-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ed729b6229442b15-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","已证"],"text":"P4双账号不仅刊发批评，还在《捕鼠器》中建立了后出汇编入口。","textSha256":"7f6bfacfea2235e385f729ede5c07d403d93b2e2ba7078913a6c4279027f2e6f","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-62718aa3a17ffa99-1","anchor":"p-62718aa3a17ffa99-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-62718aa3a17ffa99-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","已证"],"text":"后续招募文本出现全环节共创与“无门槛、无要求”等可比较表述。","textSha256":"f27799668e51f859e6ee0a3723afcf533a9c763a238b2b8fe200b8a4f369124e","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d16d30b6e9ece41b-1","anchor":"p-d16d30b6e9ece41b-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d16d30b6e9ece41b-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","已证"],"text":"2022年11月，曲文豪公开反省从合作滑向支配、从面向观众滑向听不见批评的风险。","textSha256":"689eeddc92d8bcca760926a3a8d50757ddaf202bb93efc7b68a9689836dfc4a4","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-8e0a84ef04816550-1","anchor":"p-8e0a84ef04816550-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-8e0a84ef04816550-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","候选"],"text":"候选","textSha256":"64af28c772819137ebc61e430d21335d28968c75dde39ecf0ed82e1eb37f1934","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d5040d44d0d6ee98-1","anchor":"p-d5040d44d0d6ee98-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d5040d44d0d6ee98-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","候选"],"text":"《冰山》的批评可能促成了下一项目对共创职责的写明。","textSha256":"438d056ab92b1f4620b566c60dfc76ecbdc3c39fe961bed61b42e2d1395b2685","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-14cf0b12e9a8418c-1","anchor":"p-14cf0b12e9a8418c-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-14cf0b12e9a8418c-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","候选"],"text":"《冰山》2.0的开放招募可能是对早期门槛和组织失败的修正。","textSha256":"6581aa56a0d83635a7c3312351a95f0df2b3afca8bacdf56f08b0cd4c838a426","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d7341ee55a1fefb3-1","anchor":"p-d7341ee55a1fefb3-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-d7341ee55a1fefb3-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","候选"],"text":"同期批评的公开可能主要完成了“表达返回”，尚未完成“决定返回”。","textSha256":"93e74a00ff4d665f08eaa3c0c3151ed908f7c85561246b23f6b3244d6e91b8e7","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4ed64b572b537a88-1","anchor":"p-4ed64b572b537a88-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4ed64b572b537a88-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"缺证","textSha256":"a915df22245a6cbc6337bde7e3ad28390e19ead1350ad92b6ea790165311ee40","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-84906ac07837579c-1","anchor":"p-84906ac07837579c-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-84906ac07837579c-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"1月6日各文章的投稿、编辑、发布时间顺序与作者复核记录；","textSha256":"5a9a4b10d0d528c2a963fe5be6502bcb4a234258ae692b91ecd0f90079a5ba0f","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-79e13c3be1f458c5-1","anchor":"p-79e13c3be1f458c5-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-79e13c3be1f458c5-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"演后谈完整录音、现场主持人、发言名单和未公开意见；","textSha256":"e2e0960c301cd73e324bdb6f8b9bfcd12ff22d3fdd4119e0b41b002b1c5cf2fc","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-371ef29646b23382-1","anchor":"p-371ef29646b23382-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-371ef29646b23382-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"对批评的正式议程、决定者、采纳／驳回理由与答复；","textSha256":"5042600ae3b6fea4bccc62bb0948656cca37c50240279429a5e85b0ba8800145","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4d04900c0bb49547-1","anchor":"p-4d04900c0bb49547-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-4d04900c0bb49547-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"《冰山》1.0、《漩涡》《冰山》2.0的规则版本差与实际执行；","textSha256":"c85431ba2b2c9ef3c63218069aa83bc7815b03378bf79d1dba3c0eadb53f6fba","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-1ecf6f204a4fa00f-1","anchor":"p-1ecf6f204a4fa00f-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-1ecf6f204a4fa00f-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"票款、预算、报酬、排练纪律、退出、冲突处理和善后规则；","textSha256":"8565f505bd07393c518f10d54a51c230c89ab6b32350d4a4f29ef7a7a67fad9c","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-b13295aac050660f-1","anchor":"p-b13295aac050660f-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-b13295aac050660f-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"观众、演员、发起人、何发／P4与账号维护者的分别复核；","textSha256":"31ddef1dda5c31de12dfac5739dbaf3f5145e82f4fe6cf3a6f143305fba01f6e","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-c16fd760a05baad2-1","anchor":"p-c16fd760a05baad2-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-c16fd760a05baad2-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","缺证"],"text":"每位相关者当前的引用、匿名、撤回和结束选择。","textSha256":"8cfc8eb66c05921b41d29e4537a9fee2269e85fd37cbed47d61abe46af67a3d2","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-3c97f746da4e51b5-1","anchor":"p-3c97f746da4e51b5-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-3c97f746da4e51b5-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","反证条件"],"text":"反证条件","textSha256":"be723c0faae4408eb95ecad12ae9549f72e514a9273bb060a85d7eb889963d10","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-32da278f767e4b62-1","anchor":"p-32da278f767e4b62-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-32da278f767e4b62-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","反证条件"],"text":"以下任一材料出现，都可能使本案不再是负例候选：一份同期会议或聊天明确把某条观众／演员批评转写为具体规则；下一项目的运行记录证明该规则被实际调用；批评者取得提案、复核、否决或申诉权并成功使用；《冰山》2.0发起人能以同期文件说明开放招募正是对1月结果的回应。反之，若找到明确“不改”的决定、宣布的新规实际未执行，或下一项目重复相同问题的连续证据，本案才可能升级为闭合负例。","textSha256":"cabb059df44d14286b47857e565ca433fbe3d9a446c706637c706404f6465ab0","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-824736e3070d360f-1","anchor":"p-824736e3070d360f-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-824736e3070d360f-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"Owner碰撞点","textSha256":"099f4e2e441278242509e1eeb2329c860c566a57191e53330bcaeb32448c05f3","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-08e11e0cc4f88049-1","anchor":"p-08e11e0cc4f88049-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-08e11e0cc4f88049-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"1月1日演后交流由谁设计、主持和记录？它是自由发言、轮流发言，还是被点名发言？","textSha256":"fcdffbf4aa95fac9a3df984d04e68b8f90b9f1268334d4c3ff0bc3d183963f6e","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7acfd5af0cfdcff3-1","anchor":"p-7acfd5af0cfdcff3-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7acfd5af0cfdcff3-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"“15号观众”的文章由谁收取，是否经过改题、删节或合并，作者是否同意公开？","textSha256":"29594f5305287df58bbed6eae64469f76cfba421398a68ea7378e27d5fee7cc9","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ef619b1cf68f497d-1","anchor":"p-ef619b1cf68f497d-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-ef619b1cf68f497d-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"1月6日各篇的真实先后是什么；《北风致辞》回应的是现场、某篇文章，还是泛指一类观众？","textSha256":"0124496a311fbee84858b9245e61c59cc8766a2200a4de3f039c3caa1c0bd398","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bc1d5d0ca0d7bd2c-1","anchor":"p-bc1d5d0ca0d7bd2c-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-bc1d5d0ca0d7bd2c-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"谁掌握“p4剧场”和“p4剧场和你”的发布权限，谁决定《捕鼠器》的收录与排序？","textSha256":"66c2da9e7bba9ecf786df74e1887e45271b3a39b47014492b50184f106b8fb61","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-5c57d996bea77cd9-1","anchor":"p-5c57d996bea77cd9-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-5c57d996bea77cd9-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"演后是否召开过一次真正的决定会议；哪条意见被采纳、哪条被拒绝、哪条无人处理？","textSha256":"f1d5f4c55cde3a1b17b5a9533af97ab5708487749c8fa93843b4800dd6cda39e","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-69d9eaefb10c4ecf-1","anchor":"p-69d9eaefb10c4ecf-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-69d9eaefb10c4ecf-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"《漩涡》的全环节共创清单在《冰山》之前是否已经存在；若是失败后新增，具体由谁提出？","textSha256":"ade7805ee89f47ec5db06cdc9d950a9f045d7bbcc707240715eb588ade4d5c3c","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-870123169e1031ec-1","anchor":"p-870123169e1031ec-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-870123169e1031ec-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"《冰山》2.0为何改成“无门槛、无要求”；这是批评回流、人员不足、驻地条件，还是另一原因？","textSha256":"9e6e9115d862b50b8846675bf5c7118012acd1bdc7fdf9b4211b28a269cd657d","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-000c4a495ec01a91-1","anchor":"p-000c4a495ec01a91-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-000c4a495ec01a91-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"对“观众受骗／不受尊重”的批评，后来是否出现过预期说明、退票、答复期限或申诉程序？","textSha256":"8e7dd22d1cc08221eba836870ae86700f29ab1478f46a3c6234fae19b7d07ae9","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0599f18b0d4e87db-1","anchor":"p-0599f18b0d4e87db-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-0599f18b0d4e87db-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"哪位演员、观众或维护者能指出：公开文章之外，实际工作方式究竟变了什么？","textSha256":"a0c7ce3461e67d7baf17692041b5336b8bda806bb2cecd5a648d82a763d9c864","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-412f21ff6797063c-1","anchor":"p-412f21ff6797063c-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-412f21ff6797063c-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"有哪些意见没有进入公众号，谁决定不发，原稿是否还在？","textSha256":"5ea2e8656af8236ecd8e9e5f7a2d8787a8e9883c7ef82e3cbdbf0e36987ea77d","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7ad9ee521b36f4ad-1","anchor":"p-7ad9ee521b36f4ad-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-7ad9ee521b36f4ad-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"15号观众及其他作者今天是否愿意进入本书，允许怎样称呼、引用和退出？","textSha256":"ad7fbb411222f69736fbd34ba2a540b7ee98ae503dac297fd7a1b893b4d3f4a8","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e2e8b80eb667c21e-1","anchor":"p-e2e8b80eb667c21e-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-e2e8b80eb667c21e-1","kind":"li","headingPath":["八、阶段裁决","Owner碰撞点"],"text":"如果他们要求本案结束，哪些正文、引文与档案索引应立即停止使用？","textSha256":"156dd5a7bb8bc5e2e918500dedc71c7a1826eb287204a3facbc968fd0ae9b081","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-6bf8d8dff61bde8a-1","anchor":"p-6bf8d8dff61bde8a-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-6bf8d8dff61bde8a-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核"],"text":"九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","textSha256":"613b0f3981c9b7b0bd5102407cace9753d47e1451a090e7df8c0da2204a5ae78","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-015841815365662f-1","anchor":"p-015841815365662f-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-015841815365662f-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","后续节点使“没有改变”更难成立"],"text":"后续节点使“没有改变”更难成立","textSha256":"601660ecf6b31fab9d15af6b5044b06a43505637fa2a8d41f3fff6632224159a","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-21b6f98484611f14-1","anchor":"p-21b6f98484611f14-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-21b6f98484611f14-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","后续节点使“没有改变”更难成立"],"text":"本轮不是继续搜集“P4曾经反思过”的文本，而是检查负例所需的反事实链。2022年2月8日的 《漩涡》招募 把全环节集体创作写得更具体；4月8日的 《冰山》2.0招募 又出现“无门槛、无要求”的开放表述；11月30日的 后出自我批评 则承认合作可能滑向支配、批评可能被“听不见”。","textSha256":"9b74f8ea1df99a62feda4069503b9f960219a4d7869915d4d98bbc54f4ab3528","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-600d0a347e0dc2a0","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d59ccdce6d3139bc","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-e806de5aa6c5f451"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-87c6620da6a617bf-1","anchor":"p-87c6620da6a617bf-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-87c6620da6a617bf-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","后续节点使“没有改变”更难成立"],"text":"这些节点不能证明1月的批评已经造成改规，却会阻止我们把本案轻易判成“什么都没有变”。后续文本至少呈现了不同的制度候选：共创职责被明写、招募门槛被重述、发起人对“听不见”做出了公开承认。如果不能证明这些差异与旧惯例无关、没有执行，或在实际冲突中失效，就不能用“后来仍无变化”来封口。","textSha256":"280cf4c7160eb72f2cca42dc0cac297867ce91f09599418746a021e27cb08ec9","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-2482f50527b13a70-1","anchor":"p-2482f50527b13a70-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-2482f50527b13a70-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","缺口仍在决定层与执行层"],"text":"缺口仍在决定层与执行层","textSha256":"41067bd7fb75734ca4e05e0bfb334a7e9e8a73e0159721d2f134b4eed4e81a3f","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-286263ce033aebd7-1","anchor":"p-286263ce033aebd7-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-286263ce033aebd7-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","缺口仍在决定层与执行层"],"text":"第二轮复核仍未找到以下链条：哪一条《冰山》观众或成员批评被哪个人或会议纳入议程；决定了修改、不修改还是暂缓的具体理由；新规则何时被写入招募、排练或演出运行；它在一次真实冲突中是否被调用；提出批评的人是否能复核“这是我的意见造成的差异”。现有公开文本完成的仍然主要是表达、编辑和归档，而不是从返回到决定、从决定到执行的责任链。","textSha256":"eae60fbdaa41c4e98e4177c68bde695a851e63b348c41c03db171408b09a057c","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-1525ac06b4590353-1","anchor":"p-1525ac06b4590353-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-1525ac06b4590353-1","kind":"h3","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","第二轮裁决"],"text":"第二轮裁决","textSha256":"d57f55d1d1011dab6b869187cd488fb010298b98de38bff36d7d75c4f39212b2","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a679ecd1b0a235e4-1","anchor":"p-a679ecd1b0a235e4-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a679ecd1b0a235e4-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["九、2026-07-14第二轮闭合差额复核","第二轮裁决"],"text":"本案继续保持 candidate_not_closed 。它不是闭合的负例，也不能因为后续出现差异文本就升级为正例。当前最准确的说法是： 批评的表达返回与档案返回已经可见；决定返回、可归因的规则差和执行结果仍未闭合；而后续变化候选又使“旧惯例明确未变”同样无法成立。","textSha256":"2defe744b9d7767431f0d618b2b143efd5bcce396deb0c895b4dc5f0bfed75d6","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-db223fad35422792-1","anchor":"p-db223fad35422792-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-db223fad35422792-1","kind":"h2","headingPath":["十、研究接线"],"text":"十、研究接线","textSha256":"36ea513dcddb5b97dd7157f186383bfc22a4ff6e79269806f26cb32109a038aa","links":[],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-2a882d0e87f435f5-1","anchor":"p-2a882d0e87f435f5-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-2a882d0e87f435f5-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["十、研究接线"],"text":"本案用 递归媒介学 检验批评是否返回决定，以 事件组织权 追问谁采纳或拒绝，以 结束权 限制对批评者的继续调用； 冰山 只提供项目关联，不预先裁定组织效果。P4剧场（馆内参考，未随本文公开）与何发（馆内参考，未随本文公开）分别作为平台／组织和具名叙述位置出现，不能覆盖北风成员、观众与退出者。","textSha256":"efdedcd8a4e4ccf92736977e103a8f0b17ecf114217d46c18193157cba382699","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-2f722f0857fe160a","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-78e468fde7b8b530","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-b179272bf6c7ab2d","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-f035448f2c6ed356"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a5cfb035c90030cd-1","anchor":"p-a5cfb035c90030cd-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-a5cfb035c90030cd-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["十、研究接线"],"text":"语料边界回到P4网站与705篇公众号语料库（馆内参考，未随本文公开）。批评前结构只把 《给百分之九十的人写戏》 与 《冰山》首演开票 作为公开主张；同期内部异议另接 《撕掉我的名字》 。后续位置材料包括 1月30日招募 、 5月观察日记 与 7月18日后出回溯 ；它们只构成日期、公开叙述或变化候选，不能补出批评因果。","textSha256":"cbab29ae869b5febfdbb8568b9dfa856c7bc7f29f6fd3b674610444798ab02d4","links":["https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-2ab7eda2cb8bf062","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-896079b3f7acd0b7","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-9771b16474ec7848","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-a764223f1db662cc","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-ad47ec028c39e2a0","https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-e74ef300e46711e2"],"images":[]},{"id":"hs-d2519250a5329780#p-19de2dd392a9d97b-1","anchor":"p-19de2dd392a9d97b-1","url":"https://a.p4theater.top/research/hs-d2519250a5329780#p-19de2dd392a9d97b-1","kind":"p","headingPath":["十、研究接线"],"text":"候选状态回到第八章负例总入口（馆内参考，未随本文公开），当事人口述入口在第八章问卷（馆内参考，未随本文公开）；权利与规则差字段沿用P4条件反写账本（馆内参考，未随本文公开），不因字段齐全而假定事实齐全。","textSha256":"2eab4bc3fed9c30a73cea4c39d7da899c17aa55d8f39eac6ff8e10bc333b8c28","links":[],"images":[]}]}